Key facts
Relevance
AS/A Physics
Time: 60 minutes
Downloadable resources
Teacher guidance
Download with detailed advice for teachers (pdf, 40K)
Activities
Resources:OHTs, background information and student sheets for the lesson (pdf, 185K)
Whilst observable phenomena often provide the starting point for new scientific understandings, scientists can use abstract ideas and analogies to develop new theoretical models.
By using an analogy to link a poorly understood area of science with a well understood area of science scientists are able to draw upon old resources to solve new problems.
Scientists need to be able to recognise those analogies that are useful. Useful analogies might link areas of science previously considered as separate. Useful analogies can also generate predictions that can be tested.
The lesson aims to develop students understanding of the role of theoretical models in science. In particular that models:
This lesson consists of three activities.
This activity is set in the contexts of the electromagnetic 'catapult' effect and the kinetic theory of gases. Working as a whole class, and then in small groups, students place statements from these contexts on a spectrum ranging from ‘observable phenomena/objects’ to ‘abstract ideas’.
Using the resources provided, the teacher presents the main features of Faraday's ideas about magnetic field lines and Maxwell's model of magnetic vortices. Working in pairs students then discuss their responses to a set of questions about these two models before the teacher takes feedback and gives the appropriate responses for each of the questions.
Students use the kinetic theory of gases to make a prediction that there is a minimum temperature
©The Nuffield Foundation 2003